Skip to main content
What is the difference between the Celluloid Score, Metascore and Tomatometer?

The Tomatometer is the share of critics who liked a title. The Metascore is a weighted average of critics’ scores. The Celluloid Score averages up to four labelled inputs, including the Metascore, IMDb and Letterboxd ratings and our editor’s rating, and leaves out audience sentiment. Each answers a different question, so read them side by side.

Celluloid terms

Celluloid Score

Celluloid’s own 0–100 composite. It averages the available Celluloid Editorial Rating, Metascore, Letterboxd rating (×20) and IMDb rating (×10), with missing inputs left out rather than counted as zero. It is published only for released titles with at least two real inputs.

Celluloid Editorial Rating

The named editor’s own 0–100 assessment of a title. It is one person’s rating, not a percentage of several critics, and it is never derived from an aggregator.

Audience snapshot

A 0–100 indication of audience sentiment shown on title pages. It is displayed for comparison and excluded from the Celluloid Score, because sample size and provenance vary by market.

Celluloid Pick

A title with a Celluloid Score of 90 or more. Recommended covers 60–89 and Not Recommended is below 60. These tiers are Celluloid’s labels, not Rotten Tomatoes’ Certified Fresh.

Review Pending

The title is catalogued but has no Celluloid Score yet. It is not a zero or a fail: it means the two-input floor and editorial verification have not been met.

Critics roundup

A summary of other critics’ published reviews. Celluloid has not screened the title for a roundup, gives it no rating, and marks it up as an article rather than a review. A festival review roundup does the same for festival coverage.

In-depth review

A long-form review based on a direct viewing, covering performance, craft and who the film is not for. It carries the editor’s rating.

Ratings from other sites

Metascore

Metacritic’s 0–100 score for a film, show, game or album. Metacritic assigns scores to reviews from a selected group of critics and publishes their weighted average.

Tomatometer

Rotten Tomatoes’ score: the percentage of professional critic reviews that are positive for a film or TV show. It measures how many critics liked a title, not how much.

IMDb rating

The weighted average of the 1–10 ratings that registered IMDb users give a title. IMDb updates the average several times a day rather than with every vote.

Letterboxd rating

The average of Letterboxd members’ star ratings, on a scale of half a star to five stars. Celluloid multiplies it by 20 to put it on a 0–100 scale.

Age ratings

BBFC age rating

The UK classification for films and videos (U, PG, 12A, 12, 15, 18 and R18), set by the British Board of Film Classification against its published guidelines.

MPA rating

The US film rating (G, PG, PG-13, R and NC-17) given by the Motion Picture Association’s Classification and Rating Administration, as guidance for parents.

Spotted a definition that is out of date? See our corrections log for how to tell us.